Before Philosophy Day, Ask What Would Change Your Mind

Jonathan Anthony Burkett — author portrait
Jonathan Anthony Burkett. Author-supplied portrait.

By Jonathan Anthony Burkett

Original reflections | November 17, 2026

A disagreement can continue long after both people understand the words being used. Each person gives another example, repeats the point and wonders why the conversation is not moving. At that stage, a different question may be useful: what would make either of us revise the position? The question does not demand an immediate surrender. It asks what kind of reason the conversation is looking for. If every possible answer would be dismissed in advance, the exchange may be serving a purpose other than investigating the claim being discussed.

UNESCO’s World Philosophy Day 2026 event listing announces a November 19 gathering at its headquarters in Paris. On November 17, that remains an upcoming event, not a discussion whose outcomes can already be reported. UNESCO’s observance page connects philosophy with thinking, dialogue and the reasoned examination of opinions. The following is a newly composed reflection by Jonathan Anthony Burkett, not an account of attending the event or a quotation from its speakers. It brings a question about revising an opinion into an ordinary, hypothetical conversation.

Give the opinion a shape that can be examined

Imagine two friends discussing whether a weekly community gathering should move to another day. One says the current arrangement works. The other says it excludes people. Before debating the conclusion, they can identify what each statement concerns. Does works mean the room is available, attendance is steady or the organizers can manage the preparation? Does excludes refer to a known scheduling conflict or a broader concern that has not been explored? A concrete claim gives both people something to investigate. A broad label can conceal several different questions inside one confident sentence.

The friends can then ask what information would matter. Perhaps they need to hear from people whose work hours conflict with the meeting. Perhaps the alternative room has a limitation neither has checked. These are hypothetical possibilities, not findings about a real organization. Naming them makes the disagreement more useful because the next step becomes something other than repeating a preference. Each person can describe which information would strengthen, weaken or change their view. The discussion begins to reveal the relationship between the position and the reasons offered for holding it.

There may be a value that does not disappear when more information arrives. One friend may prioritize a predictable routine, while the other prioritizes a different kind of access. Evidence about attendance can inform the decision without automatically deciding how those values should be balanced. It helps to say that openly. Otherwise, people may keep requesting more facts while actually disagreeing about which tradeoff is acceptable. A conversation can become more honest when it distinguishes an unknown condition from a choice about what the group is willing to prioritize.

Make room for a partial revision

Changing an opinion need not mean reversing every part of it. A person might conclude that the current day remains workable but that the start time needs review. Someone else might keep the concern about access while revising a claim about who is affected. A partial revision is still a response to the conversation. It should not be treated as a trick because it does not produce total agreement. The purpose of examining an opinion is to make it more responsible to reasons, not necessarily to make both people end with identical sentences.

That distinction also affects how a change is received. If every revision is greeted as a humiliating defeat, the conversation may make reconsideration socially expensive. A friend can acknowledge that new information changed the picture without turning the moment into a contest. This is an original observation about discussion, not a promise that one phrase will resolve a difficult relationship. The participants still have their own feelings and choices. But they can avoid making confidence the only response that earns respect, especially when the available information was incomplete at the beginning.

A person can also admit that they do not yet know what would change their mind. That answer may reveal a question worth thinking about privately before continuing. It does not have to be used as an accusation. Some opinions are held as habits long before their reasons have been put into words. Asking about revision can make that structure visible. The next conversation may be better if each person takes time to identify the claim, the reasons and the uncertainty instead of demanding an instant performance of complete philosophical clarity.

Decide what the conversation can actually settle

An ordinary discussion has limits. The friends in the example may not have authority to change the gathering’s schedule. They can still decide what information to seek and how to bring the question to the people responsible. Their conversation should not be represented as a decision already made on behalf of everyone. A useful outcome might be an accurate question for a meeting, a request for current information or a clearer statement of the disagreement. Those are meaningful results even when the final choice belongs elsewhere.

The habit can also travel into reading. A reader approaching a personal account can notice what the text states, what they infer and what remains outside their knowledge. Jonathan Anthony Burkett’s official books page provides a starting point for exploring his writing. Engaging with an author’s work does not require pretending to know the author’s present private circumstances. The same attention to reasons and limits can make a reading response more precise: this passage changed a question I brought, while another question remains open.

Before World Philosophy Day, the practical invitation is to examine one opinion gently enough that its reasons can become visible. What is the claim? What information bears on it? What would lead to a revision, and which value still requires a choice? Those questions do not guarantee agreement. They can, however, give a disagreement a more informative next step. A conversation becomes worth continuing when each participant can understand how another person is thinking and can explain how their own thinking might respond to something they have not yet considered.

#upstormed #jonathananthonyburkett #jonathanburkett #WorldPhilosophyDay #EverydayQuestions

Comments

Leave a Reply