
By Jonathan Anthony Burkett
Original reflections | October 19, 2026
An image can be genuine while its caption gives the wrong impression. A photograph from another year can be presented as if it were taken today. A close view can leave a reader guessing about the wider scene. A confident sentence can quietly supply a place, a motive or an identity that the writer has never checked. Before asking only whether an image looks believable, it is worth asking what the words around it are asking us to believe.
UNESCO lists Global Media and Information Literacy Week 2026 for October 24–31, with the theme “We All Play a Part – Media and Information Literacy for the People.” Its campaign includes #WeAllPlayAPart. As the week approaches, I suggest a small household or classroom exercise: make one accurate caption for a photograph you are entitled to use. The exercise below is my own practical reflection, not a UNESCO lesson plan or a claim about the outcome of its events.
Begin with a picture whose origin you know
Choose something ordinary and low stakes: a photograph of a meal you prepared, a street scene you took or an object on a desk. Avoid starting with a distressing event or another person’s private moment. The aim is to practice the relationship between evidence and description. An everyday image can provide plenty to discuss without requiring participants to investigate a stranger or circulate material that someone never agreed to share.
Write down what is directly known about the image. Who took it? When was it made? What does the photographer know from being there, and what can a viewer see without that explanation? These are different kinds of knowledge. A person looking at a photograph of a closed door may see a sign, but they cannot necessarily know why the door is closed. The photographer’s additional information should be identified rather than smuggled into the image as if it were visible.
This distinction is useful even when everybody trusts one another. Trust does not make every guess correct. People may remember the day differently or be uncertain about the precise time. A caption can acknowledge an approximate date if that is all that is available. Accuracy sometimes means using less detail. A missing fact is not an invitation to supply the most plausible story and then forget that it began as a guess.
Draft the plainest useful sentence
Ask each participant to write a short description without assigning emotions or motives to the people pictured. A person may be looking away; that alone does not establish that they are angry, bored or uninterested. Someone may be standing apart from a group without being excluded. Compare the descriptions and notice where observation turns into interpretation. This is not a contest to find the coldest language. It is practice in recognizing what a sentence is doing.
Then decide which contextual detail would genuinely help a reader. A location may matter. The fact that the photograph was taken during a rehearsal rather than a performance may matter even more. A caption does not need every available fact, but it should not omit the detail that changes the meaning of the scene. Choosing that detail requires thinking about the reader’s likely understanding, not merely the writer’s intention.
Try reading the sentence without the picture. What would you imagine? Now return to the image and ask whether the caption has supplied a larger event than the evidence supports. Words such as everyone, always or abandoned can do a great deal of work. Replace an unsupported claim with a description you can explain. The result may be less dramatic, but a reader receives a clearer account of what is actually known.
Make editing part of the conversation
If the image has been cropped or adjusted in a way that matters to its meaning, discuss that choice. A crop can be perfectly reasonable, yet it can also remove relevant context. Compare the wider view with the smaller version. Ask what each helps the viewer see and what each leaves outside the frame. This does not require treating all editing as deception. It requires taking responsibility for how presentation directs attention.
Permission belongs in the exercise too. Knowing the origin of a photograph does not automatically mean that every person pictured wants it published. Consider whether the image needs to be shared at all, whether a person should be asked and whether identifying information is necessary. A practice caption can stay on the kitchen table. The learning does not depend on turning every activity into content for an audience.
For younger participants, keep the task manageable and welcome uncertainty. An adult can model checking a date rather than pretending to remember it. A child can point out a visible detail an adult missed. The shared purpose is to improve a description, not expose somebody as foolish. A useful correction becomes easier to accept when changing the sentence is treated as part of the work rather than a loss of status.
Finish with a description you can stand behind
The final caption should allow someone else to understand the picture without borrowing certainty the writer does not possess. That might include a simple attribution, a verified date and a sentence explaining the activity. If something remains unknown, decide whether it belongs in the caption at all. A question can remain a question. There is no need to fill every gap before a modest image becomes worth looking at.
This small exercise will not resolve every information problem. Its value is that it makes one familiar act of publishing visible. People can see how a word is chosen, how a claim is supported and how an error is corrected before the sentence travels. In a changing media environment, creating a careful description is a way to participate with more responsibility. The next caption becomes an opportunity to practice that care again.
#upstormed #jonathananthonyburkett #jonathanburkett #WeAllPlayAPart #MediaLiteracy #GlobalMILWeek

Leave a Reply